Photo#1: Western Pleasure- Why the lake background? Not appropriate for WP. Doll has issues: Blouse is too loose, needs to be. ore form fitted. Chaps are ill fitting, bulky and too long. Arms are wonky- arms should have some bend at the elbows and hands need to be turned appropriately. Toes are pointing down, heels should be down, not toes. Bosal is too big for model's nose. The PS TB is not a great choice for WP, IMO. The tail is too elevated, indicating some excitement which is not something western judges typically like to see (some exceptions per breed, of course).
Photo #2: Western Bareback- I'm not sure what this scene is supposed to be? Is this a casual bareback ride beside a lake? If so, why the fancy show clothes on the doll? Same issues with the doll as in photo 1. Arms wonky, blouse too loose, chaps don't fit and way too long...can't even see her boot. Bosal fits this horse's nose better but lead line on mecate periously low
I meant to add that these photos are good examples of why judges tell you that if your doll is not done well, it might be better to leave it off. The doll's problems detract from the picture. She could be fixed with some adjustments to her clothing and positioning, though. Also, a good tip is to try to zero in on what you are trying to portray. If there are elements that don't match up (lake background in WP class, fancy show clothes in a casual trail ride, rider not positioned as she should be, tack that doesn't fit, etc.), try to get rid of all the inconsistencies. Your setup should be *exactly* what you would expect to see in real life with nothing detracting from the picture.
Kathy Williams, long time QH breeder and AQHA & Open western shower
My comments are along the same line as Kathy's. Doll riders are an art unto themselves. If not used properly they can detract from the overall effect and you won't place. On photo #1, most of my concerns revolve around the doll - heels should always be down and her butt doesn't fit the saddle well (she's sitting up too high, which is why I think her feet aren't fitting the stirrups correctly). Photo #2 - lead line is a huge problem and the doll looks like she'll be falling off the horse momentarily. Linda Watson, ancient judge.
Photo#1: Western Pleasure- Why the lake background? Not appropriate for WP. Doll has issues: Blouse is too loose, needs to be. ore form fitted. Chaps are ill fitting, bulky and too long. Arms are wonky- arms should have some bend at the elbows and hands need to be turned appropriately. Toes are pointing down, heels should be down, not toes. Bosal is too big for model's nose. The PS TB is not a great choice for WP, IMO. The tail is too elevated, indicating some excitement which is not something western judges typically like to see (some exceptions per breed, of course).
ReplyDeletePhoto #2: Western Bareback- I'm not sure what this scene is supposed to be? Is this a casual bareback ride beside a lake? If so, why the fancy show clothes on the doll? Same issues with the doll as in photo 1. Arms wonky, blouse too loose, chaps don't fit and way too long...can't even see her boot. Bosal fits this horse's nose better but lead line on mecate periously low
I meant to add that these photos are good examples of why judges tell you that if your doll is not done well, it might be better to leave it off. The doll's problems detract from the picture. She could be fixed with some adjustments to her clothing and positioning, though. Also, a good tip is to try to zero in on what you are trying to portray. If there are elements that don't match up (lake background in WP class, fancy show clothes in a casual trail ride, rider not positioned as she should be, tack that doesn't fit, etc.), try to get rid of all the inconsistencies. Your setup should be *exactly* what you would expect to see in real life with nothing detracting from the picture.
ReplyDeleteKathy Williams, long time QH breeder and AQHA & Open western shower
My comments are along the same line as Kathy's. Doll riders are an art unto themselves. If not used properly they can detract from the overall effect and you won't place. On photo #1, most of my concerns revolve around the doll - heels should always be down and her butt doesn't fit the saddle well (she's sitting up too high, which is why I think her feet aren't fitting the stirrups correctly). Photo #2 - lead line is a huge problem and the doll looks like she'll be falling off the horse momentarily. Linda Watson, ancient judge.
ReplyDelete